THE PROBLEM
TROUBLE IN AMERICA
When the average six-year-old
child enters first grade, he or she already knows the meaning of about 26,000 words.
They may not use all of those words themselves, but they understand what the words
mean when they hear them.
The goal of many first grade reading programs is to teach the students to read between
200 and 600 common words by the end of the school year. Sadly, over half of them
can’t even read 100 words by the time they finish first grade.
In fact, many of them never learn to read well at all. In the
United States, over half of the adults can’t read material written at the sixth grade level.
How did this come to pass? The answer lies in the fact that John Dewey, the “Father
of Progressive Education” and Arthur Gates, an influential educator, changed the
way reading was taught in this country. Before these changes were made everyone
who attended school learned to read in a very short time. In our large cities, over
90 percent of the adult population could read anything written in our language.
Dewey and Gates proposed that our schools abandon the method that had been used
to teach reading ever since reading was first invented. As a result, we now have
an epidemic of poor reading in t his country.
Millions of children and adults are paying a terrible price because of what these
men and other educators of their time did. It is imperative in a country as large
and diverse as ours that everyone learn to read well. Yet many of our citizens are
severely handicapped because they have not been taught to read by the only method
that works every time.
Our only hope of putting
America
back on the right track is to return to teaching reading by the method that has
worked for thousands of years. It is called phonics, and if it were properly used
in the schools of
America
today, those six-year-old students would be able to read 35,000 to 40,000 words
by the time first grade was over.
IDENTIFYING THE PROBLEM
In the United States, approximately
40 to 45 percent of school aged children are below grade level in reading.1
Of the 40 percent who have difficulty with reading, approximately 80 percent are
boys.2 Male and female brains, while similar in many respects, often
function differently when processing the same or similar tasks. This is a result
of physiological differences in the neural architecture of the brain over which
neither the male nor female has any conscious control. These differences are graphically
illustrated by magnetic resonance images taken during various activities.
Brain activation patterns show that males process reading in a relatively small
area in the left hemisphere of the brain, while females typically process reading
in significantly larger areas of both sides of the brain.3
We also know that females are typically better able to infer, that is, to draw conclusions
from intuitive, inferential stimuli or incomplete data, than are males. Males, especially
those who have difficulty with reading, do not generally have the ability to draw
conclusions from inference or extrapolation. Those in this group require a directed,
factual approach in order to arrive at conclusions.
The male in the 40 percent group is generally unable to draw abstract conclusions,
and is thus unable to infer that letters are symbols that stand for sounds. He must
be taught every possible sound represented by each letter and combination of letters,
plus dependable rules that govern the sounds those letters make. Until he learns
this, he will have difficulty reading.4
The females in this group process very similarly to the males. They too have difficulty
making the necessary inferences. That is why they benefit greatly from a phonological
approach that covers the 44 sounds of American English.
For a complete understanding of how our alphabetic system works, the child must
have a thorough grasp of this information:
1.
The ability to analyze words into phonemes.
2.
The knowledge that these phonemes occur in all words.
3.
The knowledge of which letter symbol represents which phoneme.
4.
The understanding that there is a consistent relationship between each phoneme
and a letter across all positions in a word and across all words (transitivity).
The letter b stands for the phoneme /b/ in the word ‘big,’ and also for /b/ in the
word ‘bat,’ and also for /b/ in the word ‘tub.'5
The Academic Associates Reading Program is designed to address the problem in
a simple straightforward manner. Students are given the phonetic skills to master
over 90 percent of the million words in the English language.
In Marcia D’Arcangelo’s very recent interview with Sally Shaywitz, professor of
pediatrics at the
Yale Child Study Center
, she posed this predicament:
“Educators are vitally interested in information that can help them teach reading.
Many middle school and high school teachers haven’t been taught how to teach reading.”
Dr. Shaywitz’s reply contained, “…This [scientific] evidence supports the fact
that reading is part of language. To read, we have to break up spoken words into
smaller units, understand that letters represent sounds, have a knowledge base,
have a vocabulary, and have the motivation and enjoyment."6
When trained in teaching the Academic AssociatesTM Reading Program teachers
have the skills necessary to teach anyone to learn to read. Elementary teachers
know a lot about reading but have never been taught a program that works every time. The Academic AssociatesTM Reading Program does
for its teachers what no university or teacher’s college can do. In our reading program
we build on the first three stages of reading development.
7 Our students begin with initial decoding. An understanding of the phonetic
structure of the English language is a must if a poor reader is to become a good
reader.
We then move into fluency where the decoding becomes both accurate and rapid.
This frees up attention for higher-level reading comprehension skills.
Reading
for meaning becomes one of understanding the content. It is during this stage that
students expand their knowledge base. Students who are reading below grade-level
lack significantly in their knowledge base.
After students learn to sound out and pronounce words, they are taught simple,
effective techniques for understanding what they read.
Reading
becomes a logical, uncomplicated process.
By lesson 13, most fourth-graders through adults read and spell collegelevel words,
and comprehend material at their own grade level or higher.
This is usually accomplished in 45 to 60 hours. Out of the thousands of students
and adults who have been through the Academic Associates Reading Program, every
one has learned to read and, typically, progressed 2 to 5 grade levels in their
reading ability.
|
1This
is based on the 1994 NAEP’s reading exam of 4th graders, and Education Week 9/16/98.
2Scientific
American, "Dyslexia", by Frank R. Vellutino March 1987 page 39.
3Scientific
American, "Dyslexia", by Sally E. Shaywitz A new model of this reading disorder
emphasizes defects in the language processing rather than the visual system. It
explains how language is processed November 1996.
4 Ibib.
5 "Why Our Children Can’t Read",
by Diane McGuiness, The Free Press 1997 page 174
6 Educational Leadership, "Learning
About Learning to Read", by Marcia D’Arcangelo, October 1999 pages 26-31.
7 Journal of Learning Disabilities, "The Effect of Early
Reading
Failure on Acquisition of Knowledge Among Students with Learning Disabilities",
by Vicki Snider & Sara Tarver June/July 1987.
© Copyright 2006
Academic Associates Learning Center
|
|